Federal Disability Retirement: Further thoughts on Reasonable Accommodation by the Agency - Administrative Law Legal Blogs Posted by Robert R. McGill - Lawyers.com

Federal Disability Retirement: Further thoughts on Reasonable Accommodation by the Agency

     The problem with Agency efforts to provide an employee with reasonable accommodations is that such attempts are too often, neither "reasonable" nor legally viable accommodations.  Let’s remember that a legally viable "accommodation" is that act, allowance, or modification, which allows the employee to continue to perform and complete the core or essential elements of one’s position.  Further, Federal and Postal employees need to understand that there is nothing inherently wrong with an Agency providing an accommodation that is neither legally viable (for Federal disability retirement purposes) nor "reasonable".  Let me explain.  Let’s say that an employee works for the Postal Service.  He or she gets injured, and let’s even assume that it is a valid OWCP Department of Labor claim.  At some point, because OWCP/DOL is NOT a retirement system, they will often "create" a "modified position" and make a modified, or light-duty job offer.  It could be as extreme as sitting in a corner and answering the telephone.  Now, if the individual gets the same pay, there is nothing inherently wrong with such a modified job offer.  However, at the same time, you need to remember that accepting such a modified job offer does not preclude the employee from filing for, and getting approved, an application for Federal Disability Retirement.  This is because the modified (or "light duty") job offer is not a real, previously-vacant position, and therefore is neither "reasonable" nor truly an accommodation under federal disability retirement laws.  Nevertheless, there was nothing wrong with the Agency making up such a "modified job" and offering it to the employee.  This is true of all Agencies in the Federal Government, across the Board, from FAA Air Traffic Controllers who have lost their medical clearances, to IT Specialists who have lost their security clearances, to executive level administrators:  modified duties, and "make-up" positions, while remaining in the same position, does not mean that there is anything inherently wrong with the modified job offer.  It just means that such a modified job is neither a "reasonable" accommodation, and nor is it an "accommodation" at all — at least, not under the laws governing Federal Disability Retirement.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire

View Attorney Profile

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Unique Writer
    Posted on May 20, 2019

         These days, writers are plentiful; more and more people are publishing, and while “self-publishing” has become more acceptable, even the quantity of people writing books, novels, narratives, biographies, autobiographical works, self-help books and allegedly adventuresome travelogues portending to unique experiences has exponentially exploded in our times. Decades ago, there were only a handful ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Advice
    Posted on May 18, 2019

         The great thing about it is that most people are willing to give it out in endless streams of inarticulate bosh for free, and the rest of us are at liberty to do with it what we want. With the advent of the Internet, and more so with the consolidation of all things ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Jobs versus careers
    Posted on May 17, 2019

         We make a distinction between the two, do we not? One merely “lands” a job, whereas we “pursue” a career, implying the arbitrary nature of the first and the delectable interest shown in the second. Yet, the bifurcation of the two is never so stark as night and day, but can often be ... Read more

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Unique Writer
    Posted on May 20, 2019

         These days, writers are plentiful; more and more people are publishing, and while “self-publishing” has become more acceptable, even the quantity of people writing books, novels, narratives, biographies, autobiographical works, self-help books and allegedly adventuresome travelogues portending to unique experiences has exponentially exploded in our times. Decades ago, there were only a handful ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Advice
    Posted on May 18, 2019

         The great thing about it is that most people are willing to give it out in endless streams of inarticulate bosh for free, and the rest of us are at liberty to do with it what we want. With the advent of the Internet, and more so with the consolidation of all things ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Jobs versus careers
    Posted on May 17, 2019

         We make a distinction between the two, do we not? One merely “lands” a job, whereas we “pursue” a career, implying the arbitrary nature of the first and the delectable interest shown in the second. Yet, the bifurcation of the two is never so stark as night and day, but can often be ... Read more