FERS & CSRS Disability Retirement from the Office of Personnel Management: The Fallacy of Objective Medical Evidence - Administrative Law Legal Blogs Posted by Robert R. McGill - Lawyers.com

FERS & CSRS Disability Retirement from the Office of Personnel Management: The Fallacy of Objective Medical Evidence

The Federal Circuit Court of Appeals has already addressed the issue of the Office of Personnel Management’s unjustified adherence to making a distinction between "objective medical evidence" as opposed to what they deem and declare to be "subjective" evidence. The distinction has no statutory basis or authority, but OPM continues to make the same, repetitive and tiring arguments concerning such a distinction.  Of course, when there exists a plenitude of "objective" evidence, then OPM will often sidestep such evidence and argue that it wasn’t "compelling" enough.  The fallacy of "objective" versus "subjective" becomes most apparent, of course, when it addresses the issue of "pain".  Pain is by definition a subjective state of experiential encounter.  If there is any "objective" evidence of pain, it is a misunderstanding of what constitutes such evidence.  Thus, for instance, one might point to an MRI showing a multi-level disc degeneration from L3-L4, L4-L5, etc., and state, "There, we have objective evidence of pain."  Not quite.  What you merely have, if one stops and considers it, is simply a parallel set of observable facts:  A:  an image which reveals an abnormality of the spine, combined with B, which has an individual who conveys a sensation of pain.  However, inasmuch as there are many people who have similar or worse states of "A" (multi-level disc degeneration), but go through life without any apparent pain, one cannot therefore argue that A is "objective" evidence of "B".  There may be a parallel correlation to be made, but no causal connection.  Regardless, the Federal Circuit Court has already declared OPM to be in error for making such a distinction.  However, despite the law, OPM continues to deny Federal Disability Retirement applications under FERS & CSRS by adhering to the false distinction.  Imagine that.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire

The Federal Circuit Court of Appeals has already addressed the issue of the Office of Personnel Management’s unjustified adherence to making a distinction between "objective medical evidence" as opposed to what they deem

View Attorney Profile

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Growth Stopper
    Posted on April 24, 2019

         In life, inertness is considered “bad”; it is progress, the ascent of man and the constant striving towards attaining and achieving which are considered “good”. “Growth” and the incessant need to extend, expand and extoll the virtues of acquisition and accomplishment remain the medals of success; and whether we agree with such values, ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Having something to say
    Posted on April 23, 2019

         There are people who speak volumes in voluminous volubility, but of thinness of content and lacking of much substance. Then, there is that quiet person in the corner, perhaps distracted by someone’s glancing comment or lost in his own thoughts who, when asked about a topic of general interest to all in a ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Stop & Go
    Posted on April 22, 2019

         The rhythm of our daily lives is a reminder of who we are, how we live; and so the necessity of transportation — of driving a car, riding a bus, and even of a subway or the more traditional train; of how we ride for a time, then stop; then, ride again for ... Read more

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Growth Stopper
    Posted on April 24, 2019

         In life, inertness is considered “bad”; it is progress, the ascent of man and the constant striving towards attaining and achieving which are considered “good”. “Growth” and the incessant need to extend, expand and extoll the virtues of acquisition and accomplishment remain the medals of success; and whether we agree with such values, ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Having something to say
    Posted on April 23, 2019

         There are people who speak volumes in voluminous volubility, but of thinness of content and lacking of much substance. Then, there is that quiet person in the corner, perhaps distracted by someone’s glancing comment or lost in his own thoughts who, when asked about a topic of general interest to all in a ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Stop & Go
    Posted on April 22, 2019

         The rhythm of our daily lives is a reminder of who we are, how we live; and so the necessity of transportation — of driving a car, riding a bus, and even of a subway or the more traditional train; of how we ride for a time, then stop; then, ride again for ... Read more