FERS & CSRS Federal Disability Retirement from the Office of Personnel Management: The Apparent Independence of Each Stage - Administrative Law Legal Blogs Posted by Robert R. McGill - Lawyers.com

FERS & CSRS Federal Disability Retirement from the Office of Personnel Management: The Apparent Independence of Each Stage

In some ways, the fact that each "stage" of the process of Federal Disability Retirement is independent from each other, is a "given".   When a Federal Disability Retirement application is denied at the Initial Stage of the process, then again at the Reconsideration Stage of the process, it is considered a positive part of the administrative process that the Merit Systems Protection Board will evaluate and decide the case "de novo", or "anew" or "afresh", without regard to what the Office of Personnel Management stated, decided, affirmed or concluded.  To that extent — to have an independent eye and an evaluation unbiased by prior analysis — is a good thing.  However, when one reads the decision of the Office of Personnel Management at the Initial denial of the application, then again at the Reconsideration denial of the application, it is somewhat disconcerting that neither OPM Representatives relied upon the analysis of the other.  What this allows for, of course, is an independent review by both the Initial Stage of the application and the Reconsideration Stage of the application, and while such independence of review can be seen in a positive light (again, that one OPM Representative is not influenced or biased by the views of the other), more often than not, what happens is that the Reconsideration Stage OPM Representative merely comes up with new and previously unfounded arguments upon which to deny the application a second time.  In short, it is difficult to stabilize the arguments upon which OPM relies, in order to answer and refute them.  That is why the MSPB’s approach of viewing a case de novo is important.  For, by ignoring the malleability of OPM’s reviewing process, one may get an objective and truly independent analysis and evaluation of the case.  Independence is an important component of "fairness"; objectivity is an integral element; and integrity is the filament which holds the law together.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire

In some ways, the fact that each "stage" of the process of Federal Disability Retirement is independent from each other, is a "given".   When a Federal Disability Retirement application is denied at the Initial Stage of the process,

View Attorney Profile

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Unique Writer
    Posted on May 20, 2019

         These days, writers are plentiful; more and more people are publishing, and while “self-publishing” has become more acceptable, even the quantity of people writing books, novels, narratives, biographies, autobiographical works, self-help books and allegedly adventuresome travelogues portending to unique experiences has exponentially exploded in our times. Decades ago, there were only a handful ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Advice
    Posted on May 18, 2019

         The great thing about it is that most people are willing to give it out in endless streams of inarticulate bosh for free, and the rest of us are at liberty to do with it what we want. With the advent of the Internet, and more so with the consolidation of all things ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Jobs versus careers
    Posted on May 17, 2019

         We make a distinction between the two, do we not? One merely “lands” a job, whereas we “pursue” a career, implying the arbitrary nature of the first and the delectable interest shown in the second. Yet, the bifurcation of the two is never so stark as night and day, but can often be ... Read more

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: The Unique Writer
    Posted on May 20, 2019

         These days, writers are plentiful; more and more people are publishing, and while “self-publishing” has become more acceptable, even the quantity of people writing books, novels, narratives, biographies, autobiographical works, self-help books and allegedly adventuresome travelogues portending to unique experiences has exponentially exploded in our times. Decades ago, there were only a handful ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Advice
    Posted on May 18, 2019

         The great thing about it is that most people are willing to give it out in endless streams of inarticulate bosh for free, and the rest of us are at liberty to do with it what we want. With the advent of the Internet, and more so with the consolidation of all things ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Medical Retirement: Jobs versus careers
    Posted on May 17, 2019

         We make a distinction between the two, do we not? One merely “lands” a job, whereas we “pursue” a career, implying the arbitrary nature of the first and the delectable interest shown in the second. Yet, the bifurcation of the two is never so stark as night and day, but can often be ... Read more