OPM Decisions of Denial in FERS & CSRS disability retirement case - Administrative Law Legal Blogs Posted by Robert R. McGill - Lawyers.com

OPM Decisions of Denial in FERS & CSRS disability retirement case

     There are two elements:  competency/knowledge, on the one hand, and authority/power on the other.  When the two come together, we then have the combination resulting in a reasoned decision.  It is indisputable that an Agency has the authority and power to make administrative decisions.  On the other hand, if the Agency makes a decision without the proper competency or knowledge, then it can become a problem.  In reviewing a denial letter from the Office of Personnel Management in disability retirement cases, what is most disturbing are the following:  First, 90% of the denial letter is based upon a computer template.  The references to dates, medical reports & records reviewed, etc., comprise the remainder of the 10%.  Now, that is not to complain that OPM should or must "reinvent the wheel" each time it makes a decision — indeed, the fact that much of the decision is boilerplate, template language is not that disturbing.  What is, disturbing, however, is when — under the pretense of competency and knowledge, it makes blatant mis-statements of the law.  Some of the mis-statements are:  "The medical documentation does not show that you are totally disabled from performing your job."  There is no requirement under the law that a person needs to be "totally disabled".  Or:  "We are unable to make a determination because of the lack of objective medical evidence."  Medical evidence does not need to be "objective" as opposed to a doctor’s reasoned medical opinions.  Or:  "Fibromyalgia is a condition which waxes and wanes."  OPM is not a medical facility and has no business making medical determinations or declarations.

     The authority and power of an Agency must always be used in the context of competency and knowledge, and the Office of Personnel Management must make its decisions based upon the prevailing case laws, statutes and regulations which govern it.  It is the job of a disability retirement attorney to point out such misstatements of law.

Sincerely, Robert R. McGill, Esquire

View Attorney Profile

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: The Argument
    Posted on September 23, 2019

         You hear about such lives every now and again; of an old man declaring, “Never a raised voice in 50 years of marriage”, or: “We never argued. Bless her (or his) soul”. Leaving aside the viability of the astounding prefatory remark (i.e., that two people in this day and age could remain together ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: Spam
    Posted on September 21, 2019

        If you remember eating it as a kid, it “dates” you — for, who in this day and age eats something that is singularly unhealthy, contains high levels of fats, calories and sodium, as well as unnamed preservatives? On the other hand, the younger generation doesn’t blink an eye, and instead sees the ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: Treading Life
    Posted on September 20, 2019

         We don’t often think of it in those terms; but, in fact, that is how most of us live. Like the meek swimmer who does not want to drown, we merely tread water — sometimes calmly, often with a sense of desperation; and too often, with a fear that results in a frenzied ... Read more

Robert R. McGill

Licensed since 1988

Member at firm Robert R. McGill

AWARDS

Champion Badge Platinum

RECENT POSTS

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: The Argument
    Posted on September 23, 2019

         You hear about such lives every now and again; of an old man declaring, “Never a raised voice in 50 years of marriage”, or: “We never argued. Bless her (or his) soul”. Leaving aside the viability of the astounding prefatory remark (i.e., that two people in this day and age could remain together ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: Spam
    Posted on September 21, 2019

        If you remember eating it as a kid, it “dates” you — for, who in this day and age eats something that is singularly unhealthy, contains high levels of fats, calories and sodium, as well as unnamed preservatives? On the other hand, the younger generation doesn’t blink an eye, and instead sees the ... Read more

  • FERS OPM Disability Retirement: Treading Life
    Posted on September 20, 2019

         We don’t often think of it in those terms; but, in fact, that is how most of us live. Like the meek swimmer who does not want to drown, we merely tread water — sometimes calmly, often with a sense of desperation; and too often, with a fear that results in a frenzied ... Read more