IN A MARYLAND AUTO ACCIDENT CASE, WHEN MAY A DEFENDANT DISPUTE FAULT AT TRIAL?

There are generally two issues that come into play in an auto accident case (as in personal injury cases in general): (1) Fault (also known as "liability") and (2) Damages. In many cases, defendants will admit they were at fault and only dispute the damages, i.e., how badly you were hurt. In other cases, the defendant will try to dispute their fault, all the way to trial.

However, if the facts and the law are sufficiently clear-cut, the Court will not allow the defendant to dispute fault at trial. This is a procedure called "summary judgment": If the facts are undisputed, and it is clear under the law of Maryland that the defendant was at fault, the Court will rule that the defendant was at fault, before the trial even begins.

It is unusual for a plaintiff to win summary judgment in a car accidentcase, because there is usually a dispute as to what exactly happened in the accident, or it is a judgment call whether the defendant acted negligently, or both. But you are most likely to win summary judgment in a rear-end collision: Maryland courts have ruled that, in general, if a plaintiff is lawfully stopped on the road, and the defendant rear-ends the plaintiff, then the defendant is automatically at fault, unless there are extenuating circumstances. (But there are a lot of things that may qualify as extenuating circumstances. For example, in the recent case of Raskauskas v. Leith, decided by the U.S. District Court for Maryland, the Court held that because there was debris on the defendant’s windshield, obstructing her view, the Court could not grant summary judgment against the defendant even though she rear-ended a stopped vehicle.)

If you have any questions about proving who is at fault in your auto accident case, you should contact a Maryland car accident attorney at Chaikin, Sherman, Cammarata & Siegel, P.C.

View Attorney Profile

RECENT POSTS

  • After an Auto Accident, the First Rule is to Take Care of Your Health
    Posted on November 16, 2017
    Topic: Automobile Accidents

    Too many times in automobile collision cases, we receive calls from potential clients who waited until days or even weeks after the collision to seek medical treatment. Sometimes the reason is, “I thought I’d feel better after a few days.” Other times the reason is, “I wanted to get the advice of a lawyer first.” ... Read more

  • Maryland Extends Statute of Limitations for Child Abuse Victims to Bring La
    Posted on November 16, 2017
    Topic: Personal Injury

    On October 1, a new law in Maryland went into effect that extended the statute of limitations for child abuse victims to bring lawsuits against their abusers. A statute of limitations is a time limit for a victim to sue a wrongdoer; if the time limit expires, it becomes impossible for victims to sue. Previously ... Read more

  • To Settle a Case Without Filing a Lawsuit, Hire an Attorney Who is Willing
    Posted on August 28, 2017
    Topic: Civil Litigation Personal Injury

    I was recently approached by a relative of mine, let’s call him Evan, who believed that he was wrongfully terminated by his employer. Evan was in need of advice regarding a potential legal claim for illegal… Keep Reading. ... Read more

RECENT POSTS

  • After an Auto Accident, the First Rule is to Take Care of Your Health
    Posted on November 16, 2017
    Topic: Automobile Accidents

    Too many times in automobile collision cases, we receive calls from potential clients who waited until days or even weeks after the collision to seek medical treatment. Sometimes the reason is, “I thought I’d feel better after a few days.” Other times the reason is, “I wanted to get the advice of a lawyer first.” ... Read more

  • Maryland Extends Statute of Limitations for Child Abuse Victims to Bring La
    Posted on November 16, 2017
    Topic: Personal Injury

    On October 1, a new law in Maryland went into effect that extended the statute of limitations for child abuse victims to bring lawsuits against their abusers. A statute of limitations is a time limit for a victim to sue a wrongdoer; if the time limit expires, it becomes impossible for victims to sue. Previously ... Read more

  • To Settle a Case Without Filing a Lawsuit, Hire an Attorney Who is Willing
    Posted on August 28, 2017
    Topic: Civil Litigation Personal Injury

    I was recently approached by a relative of mine, let’s call him Evan, who believed that he was wrongfully terminated by his employer. Evan was in need of advice regarding a potential legal claim for illegal… Keep Reading. ... Read more